Recently, a video featuring Katie Prudent, a celebrated Franco-American equestrian and former US team rider and coach, has ignited a firestorm of controversy on social media. The video, a snippet from a training session under the auspices of the United States Equestrian Federation (USEF), has become a focal point for discussions on equine welfare in sports within the American equestrian community.

The Video and Its Impact

In January, Dutch Olympic silver medalist Albert Voorn shared a video on social media, showing Prudent conducting a training session for a group of five students. This video, a compilation of various clips totaling 2 minutes and 29 seconds, was taken from a three-day training event in Wellington organized by USEF. It shows Prudent teaching mechanical obstacle techniques, drawing widespread attention and sparking controversy over her teaching methods and remarks deemed by many as harsh and potentially harmful to the well-being of both horses and riders.

“I don’t want to see you getting pulled forward like a wimp. Teaching you to shorten your stirrups would take an extra hour of lesson. Nobody seems to do it correctly these days. Either you’re not listening to me, or you have the brains of birds,” – Katie Prudent

The Response and Division in the Equestrian Sphere

Prudent’s stern approach and comments in the video have faced backlash for being seen as humiliating towards young riders. Phrases like “smacking back” with a riding crop to discipline horses disobeying commands, and remarks directed towards students, have been criticized for contravening animal welfare. Voorn, a regular contributor to debates on equine welfare, expressed dismay over USEF allowing such conduct on its grounds, noting that such behavior is not conducive to the future of the sport.

READ MORE – Helgstrand’s Harsh Reality: A Deep Dive into the Scandal that Shook the Equestrian World

“I have this thing with my whip that I call ‘smacking back.’ The reason we have a whip is to use it properly when a horse refuses to obey. And horses need it!” Katie Prudent states. “You know, animal rights activists have no idea how to train a horse. Sometimes, they need a good thrashing.”

The Larger Picture

This incident has exposed deep divisions within the equestrian community over training methods. Some argue that the video represents a severe but acceptable style of coaching, while others condemn it as detrimental to riders and horses, fostering fear and aversion to the sport. Amidst the debate, there are calls for moderation in judging based on short video clips, with some defending Prudent’s overall training approach.

“I’d rather you crash him into the barrier than let him turn. With me, he wouldn’t even dare, I would have made him spin around. You’re a bit weak. You’re weak here (pointing to her head).” – Katie Prudent

Voir cette publication sur Instagram

Une publication partagée par DiaNewWaveSaddleseat🌊 (@newwavesaddleseat)

USEF’s Reaction

In response to the uproar, USEF stated it had removed problematic video excerpts from its online platform that did not align with its values. They emphasized their commitment to equine and human welfare, noting that effective communication between coach, athlete, and horse is crucial but should not compromise welfare. The federation is currently reviewing concerns related to the training session.

READ MORE – The Best Equestrian Airbag Vest: Why Helite Leads the Way in Rider Safety

As equestrian sports face increasing scrutiny regarding animal welfare, this controversy underscores the responsibility of athletes and trainers in shaping the perception of the sport. In an era where public image is paramount, and social media amplifies every misstep, it’s more important than ever for leaders in the field to exercise restraint and consideration in their words and actions.

How should equestrian sports balance tough training with animal welfare? Join the discussion.